Wikia

Wikihack

Save scumming

Talk4
2,025pages on
this wiki

When playing NetHack on a local machine (ie. not on a public server such as NAO), it is possible to sidestep the feature that makes the game so difficult: the permanence of death.

The concept of save scumming is simple: exit NetHack via the Shift-S save command, then copy the saved game from NetHack's playground to a different directory. Run NetHack again, and continue playing until you die. At this point, restore the saved files, copying them back from the temporary directory to the playground, and restart the game. Assuming the correct files were copied, the game continues as it was. This process is cheating, especially because the legitimate way to sidestep death is explore mode. On a few systems, though, it might be necessary to guard against game or system crashes, because some copies of NetHack lack a working recover program.

Save scumming can do more than allow a player to avoid death. Indeed, just about any random element (such as which prize lies at the end of Sokoban, or how much damage a monster inflicts this turn) can be sidestepped with save scumming.

Criticism Edit

Experience Edit

NetHack is designed so that death is permanent (except for the amulet of life saving, of course). This adds difficulty to the game, but also adds depth. When making a mistake might cost a week of gameplay, one thinks longer about each action, and investigates more fully the possible repercussions. It also adds excitement: taking risks with a carefully cultivated character becomes more exhilarating when the stakes are higher.

Player skills Edit

While savescumming may allow a new player to go farther in the dungeon than he or she has before, it will ultimately create a weaker player than if he or she had toughed it out. By saving and restoring games, the savescummer avoids the learning of the intricacies of NetHack, and will never learn the art of extracting him or herself from difficult positions. Death is part of the game, and a player who savescums to avoid death is not truly playing NetHack. Nethack is like playing several games of chess at the same time. Save scumming is like setting up the board so that you will win without having to think about anything at all. The ONLY reason you should back up your games is to avoid losing whole weeks of characters due to system crashes.

There are some cases where saving a game at a difficult choke point and then playing through multiple ways, trying to find a solution, can be more enlightening than dying and starting over. If you do this, you should probably not continue and finish the game for the reasons explained in the rest of this article. Using the save-preserving feature of explore mode may be a preferable means of accomplishing this. Alternatively, you can re-create the situation in a separate wizard mode game, do the testing which solution is best, and then go back to your original game. This sidesteps the entire "cheating" issue.

There are many roleplaying games that allow you to avoid death by saving and restoring your game. By savescumming, a player is missing out on the true fun of the game, at which point NetHack is far less superior to any other RPG available.

But, on the other hand... Edit

This wiki is a nest of spoilers designed to smooth over the same bumps and pitfalls that a player may seek to avoid via save scumming. So who are we to judge, eh?


Methodology Edit

The methods by which NetHack saves games differ per version. Similarly, the saved games are not necessarily compatible between versions or between platforms.

The easiest way to savescum is to start a brand new game. Once it is started, examine the directories in which NetHack is storing data and find one with a name similar to "save". Now save and exit the game. Examine the directory again, and see what files have appeared. Make a list of the files and the filename syntax (usually the player name with a number). Now restart the game and let the character die. Once again, examine the directory and see which files disappeared. After doing this you should have a good idea of what files hold the game's information.

One can write scripts to speed this process up. A list of scripts that can be used for this end follows:

NetHack provides no way to save a running game, as the game file is only created when you save and exit.

On multiuser systems Edit

On multiuser Unix systems, a typical configuration installs NetHack as setgid so that users are unable to copy save files into NetHack's playground.

However, this problem can be circumvented by running as root and using cp -p which will preserve the permissions to the file.

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki